Before the upgrade, after the controversy
Pavie has always provoked strong opinions. Before being promoted to Premier Grand Cru Classé "A" in 2012, it was already turning heads—especially in 2003, when the Parker vs. Robinson drama made headlines. The 2004 flew under that radar, but that’s precisely its charm: more finesse, less flex.
Tasting note
Dark berries, graphite, and licorice. The palate is firm and linear, with a cooler, almost minty freshness that sets it apart from surrounding vintages.
Fun fact
Pavie’s 2003 vintage sparked a legendary public disagreement between Robert Parker (who loved it) and Jancis Robinson (who called it "ridiculous"). The 2004? It kept its head down—and aged beautifully.
Score 96/100
A small note on our tasting impressions:
Many of the wines we taste come from bottles that aren’t quite sale-worthy—levels a bit low, labels too distressed, or simply not pretty enough for the spotlight. While we love the character these bottles bring, our notes are not based on a single glass alone. They reflect years of tasting experience—both within our team and from trusted friends in the wine world.
As for the fun facts?
All true (we promise)… though possibly enhanced by the gentle glow of a good glass of wine.